great need vs. breaking the law theme
The following kind of dilemma is illustrated: Is it morally okay to break certain laws if that is the only way to protect your life? A friend's life? A pet's life? Your house?
Examples
The Bynars saw no other choice than to hijack the Enterprise-D to save their homeworld in tng1x15 "11001001". If they had asked, the Federation might have said no.
12 total · 3 choice · 5 major · 4 minor
| Story | Level | Motivation |
|---|---|---|
| ahp1x39 | choice | Richard stole $450 in back wages from his boss because he was hard up for money. |
| ent3x19 | choice | Should Archer raid the Illyrian vessel and steal the warp coil he needs to repair Enterprise and continue his mission to save Earth from destruction? |
| tng1x15 | choice | The Bynars hijacked the Enterprise to save their planetary central computer. |
| ahp1x27 | major | Mr. Crabtree decided against the murder even though he desperately needed the money for his wife's treatment. |
| ahp4x16 | major | The story hinged on the idea that Eddie had robbed Miss Fox in order to save his gravely ill girlfriend. It transpires that he had not. |
| movie: Bicycle Thieves (1948) | major | Antonio in desperation tried to steal another man's bicycle at the end |
| movie: Oliver! (1968) | major | A central dilemma posed by the story is whether the various impoverished people in the story were morally justified in resorting to theft in order to stay out of the gruesome workhouses. |
| talesoftheunexpected2x16 | major | Hardy, who was broke and out of work, mugged a man. |
| ahp5x32 | minor | Joe thought twice before taking a wallet from a seemingly dead man because he need to pay the bills and was out of work. |
| ds95x16 | minor | Richard and Amsha made the decision to illegally genetically augment their dimwitted son Julian |